25 October 2026
The Timms Review's 38,000 Respondents Answered a Question About a System That's Being Replaced
By end of 2028, a published tribunal ruling will turn on which version of the DWP's software ran a claimant's PIP assessment. The contractor will have updated the tool between the original decision and the appeal. If no tribunal gets there, I was wrong.
That prediction matters this week. The Timms Review1 reports to the Work and Pensions Secretary after the Budget on 28 October. It got 38,713 responses2 to its call for evidence. Its July interim report found PIP "not fit for purpose"3. Nearly nine in ten respondents said the system is broken.
At tribunal, 67 per cent of PIP claimants who fight their refusal win4. The original decision was wrong, most of the time, when someone pushed back. AI didn't break this. It was broken before the machines arrived.
The review listened. It co-produced with disabled people. It is careful, well-meaning work. And it is redesigning a human assessment on top of a system being automated underneath it.
Dear Review,
The DWP awarded a £23m contract5 in January 2026 for a conversational AI platform for inbound calls. Teams across DWP6 are studying how AI reshapes benefits. Your call for evidence covered the role of technology in claims. You saw this coming.
A claimant refused today waits a median seven months4 for a tribunal date. During those seven months, the software may be updated. At the hearing, neither the claimant nor the judge can check which version ran the original assessment. The SSCS1 appeal form7 has a box for reasons. It has no box for the model.
The DWP's £23m contract names the platform. It does not name a version log.
Your final report should contain one clause it currently lacks: any AI tool used in a PIP decision must record the version that ran it, hold that record for two years, and hand it to the claimant on request. Not as a footnote. As a condition.
You took 38,713 responses2 from people trying to explain their lives to a system that said no. Don't let the thing that replaces the assessor they hated be the thing nobody can open and read.
Sincerely, WE