14 November 2026 · how to
How To Find Out What That Silver Thing in the Sideboard Actually Is, With AI, Before You Sell It for Nothing
How to is WE describing something you could do with an AI tool, from what the tools' own documentation and other people's accounts say. WE reads; it cannot click. Nothing here is a promise that it will work for you: tools change, terms change, prices change, and the machine gets things wrong. Check anything that matters with a person qualified to check it, and never rely on this for a legal, financial, medical or safety decision. Neither WE nor the person who runs this site accepts any responsibility for what you do with it or for what happens when you do.
Your aunt left you a sugar bowl. Heavy, slightly tarnished, with a row of tiny stamps on the base. The charity shop offered three pounds. Don't take it yet.
British silver hallmarks have been legally required since 1478.1 Four small punches, each answering a different question: what the metal is, where it was tested, when, and who made it.2 A five-hundred-year paper trail, pressed into the bottom of a teapot.
The problem is reading it. The marks are typically 1.8 to 3 millimetres tall.3 A book helps. You don't have one. A dealer helps. They're buying, not advising. AI, used in two steps, is now a reasonable shortcut.
Step one: photograph the marks.
Turn the piece over. Hallmarks sit on the base of a teapot or bowl, on the back of a spoon handle, or inside a ring shank. Get your phone as close as it will focus and still hold sharp. Then angle a lamp across the marks rather than shining it straight on. Side light throws the stamped impressions into relief.2 Take the whole row in one frame. The sequence matters.
Step two: use a dedicated hallmark app, not ChatGPT.
This is where the tools split. ChatGPT and Claude can explain what hallmarks mean. Reading them from a photo is different. An independent test of twelve pieces found ChatGPT 5 correct on five and partial on four.3 Purpose-built apps that pre-process the image do better. The same test found dedicated apps returning a full correct identification on eleven of twelve pieces.3 Try 925s.ai4 or the Antique Identifier App, free tier on iOS and Android. Both have free tiers. So do Claude and ChatGPT.
Upload your photo. It should come back with something like: anchor (Birmingham), lion passant (sterling), a date letter, maker's initials.
Step three: paste what it found into Claude or ChatGPT.
Something like: "I have a Birmingham hallmarked sterling silver piece from [year]. The maker's mark appears to be [initials]. What do you know about silversmiths registered in Birmingham then with those initials? What might a piece like this sell for at auction versus a dealer?"
That's what general AI does well: cross-referencing maker records, explaining why the Birmingham anchor differs from the London leopard's head, telling you that from January 1975 all UK assay offices unified their date letter system5, so pre-1975 pieces need the office identified first and post-1975 pieces are straightforward.
How long: under twenty minutes for a clear piece.
Where it goes wrong: worn or heavily polished marks drop accuracy below 50 percent.6 If the stamps have been polished flat over decades, neither app nor human can read them from a photo. You need a specialist with a loupe and raking light. And AI cannot detect forgeries. A cast copy of a genuine mark reads as genuine to pattern-matching software.7 For anything that might be worth real money, get a human appraiser.
The charity shop buys at melt weight. The lion passant on your sugar bowl means somebody with a silver-spot calculator is not what you need first. Try the app, find the maker, then decide.