2030 · Part 3, Who Asked
26. The Solo
The concert was on the second Saturday in February, at St Nicholas's on Deptford Green, the church with the skulls on the gateposts, and by five o'clock the flat had become a theatre that had lost its nerve.
Paul was ironing his shirt for the third time. Mama was in the bath doing scales, which in a flat over nothing meant the whole building was doing scales. Derek had come up to ask if someone was being murdered, and had stayed, because there was tea.
"She's flat," said Paul, to the shirt.
"Who?"
"Your mother. On the F. Every time." He turned the collar. "Don't tell her."
"I'm not telling her anything. She's in the bath."
"I CAN HEAR YOU," said Mama, from the bath. "I AM NOT FLAT. THE BATH IS FLAT."
Paul had slept in the box room since November, and since Boxing Day Marnie had slept in the big bed with her mother, which was like sleeping next to a small, determined bonfire that talked in its sleep about the price of butter. Paul had been cheerful for six weeks, the way a man is cheerful when he's started something and hasn't told you what, and Marnie found it worse than the screwdriver.
"What are you singing?" she said.
"I told you."
"Tell me again."
"Bring Him Home." He held the shirt up to the light. "Graham's taken it down a fourth. Lise put me forward."
"Lise put him forward because I told Lise," said Mama, from the bath.
"You'd been in the choir four days."
"Three. I'm very persuasive. And he breathes in the middle of home."
"I've stopped breathing in the middle of home."
"We'll see," said the bath.
St Nicholas's was cold in the way only an English church can be cold, as if the stone had been saving it up since 1697. There were about sixty people in coats, wine in plastic glasses, and a laminated sign that said PLEASE SILENCE YOUR DEVICES, under which somebody had written, in biro, and your houses.
Marnie sat near the front with Derek, who had brought eleven sausage rolls in a paper bag for the interval and was holding them on his knee like a cat.
The choir came in. Twenty-eight of them, in black, carrying folders. Paul was at the back on the left with the second basses, standing very straight, the way he stood in queues. Next to him was a woman who was taller than him, which almost nobody was, with grey hair cut like a monk's and a face that looked as if it had been told a joke in 1990 and was still deciding.
"Who's that?"
"That's Lise," said Derek.
"That's Lise?" Marnie had pictured someone small. French, for some reason. With a cardigan and a spare room and intentions.
"Your mum told me. On the stairs. Your mum tells me everything on the stairs. She says Lise sings lower than Paul."
"Women don't sing bass."
"That one does," said Derek, with respect.
And there, in the front row of the altos, in a black dress Marnie had last seen at her grandmother's funeral, with her hat on was her mother. She saw Marnie. She waved, with her whole arm, as if from a ship.
The accompanist was not a person. It was a grey keyboard on a stand to the right of the altar, with a small camera on a stalk pointing at the conductor, and a little screen that said, in friendly letters, MAESTRO PLUS — FOLLOWING GRAHAM. The choir had bought it when Mr Okafor's hands went. It followed the conductor's arms. It also, Paul had said, with a look, "reads the room", which nobody had been able to switch off, because it was in the settings, and the settings were in Norwegian.
The first half went the way choir concerts go. A Byrd. A Fauré. Something modern with clapping in it. The basses were load-bearing. Mama was audible. Not loud, exactly; more placed, the way a hat is placed, half a beat ahead of the other altos, with a vibrato she'd got from somewhere in about 1983 and never given back. In the Fauré she sang a note Marnie was fairly sure Fauré hadn't written, and held it, and looked pleased.
"Is that right?" whispered Derek.
"No."
"Sounds right."
"That's her gift."
Then Graham, who was from Catford and conducted like a man flagging down a taxi, turned to the audience and said, "And now, before the interval, Bring Him Home, with Paul," and Paul stepped out of the second basses and stood on his own on the altar step, in his shirt that had been ironed three times, and held his folder in both hands, and Marnie realised she had never once seen him stand on his own in front of anything.
The keyboard began. It was lovely. Slow, the way the song is, like someone walking very carefully with a full cup. The choir hummed under it. Paul opened his mouth.
And the man two rows behind Marnie got a phone call.
It was a buzz, and a light, and him fumbling, and two other people checking their phones to see whose it was, and on the grey keyboard's little screen a new line appeared, in friendly letters: ROOM ENGAGEMENT LOW. ADJUSTING.
The keyboard sped up.
Not much. Just enough. The prayer went from a prayer to a prayer with a train to catch. Paul, who could feel a wrong tempo the way other people feel a draught, went with it for a line, frowning, and then another phone lit up, because people were now checking their phones to see if their phones were the problem, and the screen said ROOM ENGAGEMENT LOW. ADJUSTING, and the keyboard went up again, and Graham's arms went slower and slower, and the keyboard went faster and faster, until a song about a man begging God for a boy's life was something you could have done aerobics to.
Paul stopped singing. He stood on the altar step with his mouth slightly open, like a man who has watched his bus leave from the wrong side of the road.
Then Mama put her folder down on her chair.
She walked out of the alto row, across the front of the altar, in her funeral dress, at a pace that said she'd been waiting all evening for something to walk across, took her hat off, and hit the keyboard with it. Twice. Once on the keys and once on the little camera.
The music stopped.
The screen said, in friendly letters: PAUSED. WOULD YOU LIKE ME TO RESUME AT A MORE ENGAGING TEMPO?
"Nie," said Mama, and put her hat back on, and walked back to the altos, and sat down.
Nobody in St Nicholas's breathed. Derek froze with a sausage roll halfway out of the bag.
Graham looked at Paul. Paul looked at Graham. Graham lifted his hands, very slightly, without music, and the choir, after a second, began to hum on their own, low and uneven and human, nobody quite together, the basses at the bottom holding it up.
And Paul sang.
He sang it unaccompanied, slowly, slower than the keyboard had ever played it, the way it's supposed to go, as if there were all the time in the world. He went up for the bit at the top and got there, somehow, a bass in a tenor's attic, and he didn't breathe in the middle of home. Marnie saw her mother's mouth move with it, and close, satisfied, as if she'd done it herself. His voice went out into the cold church, and it was big, and warm, and slightly rough at the bottom, like a good coat, and it was the voice she'd heard every morning for nine years saying have you seen my keys and she had never heard it at all.
He finished. There was a silence of exactly the right length, because the choir knew how long a thing was supposed to last. Then the church clapped so hard that the man with the phone dropped it.
Marnie got up, and said "Sorry," to Derek's knees, and went outside.
It was very cold on the steps. The skulls on the gateposts looked at the road.
The door opened behind her. It was Lise. She had a cigarette in her mouth and a lighter she shook twice before it worked.
"You're the girlfriend," she said. She was not from anywhere Marnie could place. Somewhere flat, with wind.
"Ex. Sort of. I live there. With my mother."
"I know. She told us. She tells everybody. She told the vicar you'd been offered a job in Strasbourg." Lise lit the cigarette and looked at the skulls. "Are you taking it?"
"I don't know."
"You should." She blew smoke at the road. "He was flat at the top."
"He was wonderful."
"He was wonderful and flat. They're not exclusive. I'll tell him on Tuesday." She looked at Marnie properly, the way you look at a hymn number. "You came out because of your mother."
Marnie opened her mouth to say I came out for some air.
"I came out for some air," she said.
"Mm," said Lise.
"I'm not jealous, if that's what you mean." Which was a lie, and not even a good one, and she didn't bother to count it.
"Of what? The keyboard?" Lise tapped her ash onto a skull. "I've been in that choir eleven years and nobody's ever hit Maestro. We've all wanted to." She stubbed the cigarette out on the gatepost. "Second half's the Rutter. Your mother's going to ruin it. You should come and watch."
She went back in.
Marnie stayed on the steps. After a while, through the door, she heard the Rutter start, unaccompanied, because the keyboard was sulking, and above all the other altos, half a beat ahead, with a note in it nobody had written, her mother.